Mrs O’Malley and Mr Malone 1950

4m001b 4m001

Metro-Goldwyn Mayer

It was intended to be the first movie of a comedic series starring James Whitmore (John J. Malone) and Marjorie Main (Hattie O’Malley). MGM even whomped up a nice little musical ditty played in the opening credits. Alas, it was not to be.

Malone is a perpetually-broke, skirt-chasing lawyer who inadvertently teams up with radio contest-winning Montanan, Hattie, who has read far too many murder and detective magazines for her own good.

Despite taking place entirely on board a Chicago to New York train, railroad images are far and few between. It’s a comedy/double murder mystery for these two sleuths (one professional, one amateur). Let’s give it a whirl and see what happens!


Actress Ann Dvorak (Connie Kepplar) walks past Union Pacific Railroad chair car # 1339. It’s a steel heavyweight car for sure (check those rivets), but I wasn’t able to find it in any online UP roster.  Maybe it’s just a set…. ;p


The movie starts right off with a tongue-in-cheek poke at Malone, followed up with a similar broadside at the conclusion of the film. Rather trite, even by 1950’s standards, it sets the tone for the picture which explains why there was not a second one forthcoming….

4m003 4m006

Having won the contest and seated inside a standard heavyweight coach, Hattie shakes the hands of her well-wishers and heads east from Montana reading yet another Detective scandal sheet.

4m007 4m008

Switching from the fashion magazines she was given, to the True Detective pulp she prefers, Hattie reads up on the latest sordid crime details.

4m010 4m011
4m014 4m015

Upon his release from the hoosegow, embezzler Steve Kepplar wires Malone that he’ll be arriving in LaSalle Street station, Chicago. The press, Malone and Kepplar’s ex- are on hand as they all want a piece of the stolen (and still missing) money. You can just make out a heavyweight coach behind them.

4m018 4m0204m019 4m021

The next evening, the entire ensemble are boarding “The Flyer” for New York. It’s obviously a set (it’s a B-picture, after all), but the studio managed to make up a simple boarding sign and drumhead for the smooth-sided streamliner.

As Hattie and Malone board, note the train now has corrugated, stainless steel sides.  Yes, that’s a very young Dorothy Malone talking to the porter and Marjorie Main.

4m023 4m026

Standard corridor shot on a sleeper (bedrooms to the right); Kepplar made the evening’s paper, so it’s a cinch he’s gonna be followed.

4m027 4m028

Nice little lounge car scene (I like the curved bar!) as Malone and Hattie have a drink. Message for you, sir!

4m037 4m041

Sure enough, Kepplar gets bumped off with his body dumped in Hattie’s sleeper. This leads to a series of misadventures as Malone and Hattie move the body to a less-incriminating location.

4m044 4m045
4m046 4m047

Time passes and once again the body is back in Hattie’s bedroom. This time the dynamic duo move the body…into the Ladies Room at the end of the car. Good views of bedroom interior (note the pull-down sink) and woman’s bathroom.

4m052 4m052b

The first of two “runbys” as the train hurtles through the night. Surprise! It is Southern Railway #2918 an EMD E6A. Sister engine #2919 poses for a builder’s photo.

4m054 4m0554m056 4m057

Aiieee! The body has been discovered by the blonde twins, Bessie and Jessie (as indicated by their monogrammed bathrobes). You guessed it, Hattie and Malone are moving the corpse again (this gag is becoming tiresome).

4m061 4m061b

The second runby is (looks like they changed railroads) an Atlantic Coast Line E unit (number unreadable). The ACL had PURPLE passenger locomotives with one unit preserved (ACL #501, an EMC E3, at the North Carolina Transportation Museum).

4m064 4m065

Handcuffed together as the train pulls into New York, Hattie and Malone are held captive in a sleeper. Outside the window, a view of an old-style, outside-braced boxcar as well as a Santa Fe “Chief to California” billboard boxcar.

4m066 4m067

The Flyer pulls into New York (complete with high-level platforms); to their astonishment, Malone and Hattie are met with a full brass band.

4m069 4m071

The chase is on…both inside the day coach and along the platform. The studio plastered, “N Y C & W R” on the letterboard of the streamlined car (the fictitious New York, Chicago & Western Railroad, perhaps?).

4m076 4m077

Trackside, the handcuffed Hattie/Malone combo deliver a haymaker on the bad guy; Up inside the station, Malone puts the finger on the guy who done it (The mug in the sailor suit).

I think MGM was trying to gin up a little Ma and Pa Kettle movie magic with Mrs O’Malley and Mr Malone. Whereas the Kettle series of 10 films – coincidentally starring Marjorie Main – were popular, M.O.& M.M. fell flat and wasn’t repeated.

This is another B-picture train movie filmed at night almost entirely on a set, so the actual train quotient is pretty low. For my money, the best B picture of this genre is still the 1952 version of Narrow Margin.

Here’s what IMDb has to say about Mrs. O’Malley and Mr. Malone:

If you have ANY information about this movie, please contact me at:


About Lindsay Korst

Webmaster, Blogmaster, Ferroequinologist - Lindsay Korst works for a nationwide home improvement center after a 20+ year career supporting computer users. A resident of the Seattle area since 1976, he has had a life-long interest in railroads, particularly those in the Pacific Northwest. He is an enthusiastic participant in the Great Northern Railway Historical Society. He and his wife reside in Redmond, Washington.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s